I built this Commander deck just using cards I have pulled from packs I opened in previous HIVE posts. I think everything here has been featured in one way or another.
Problem 1: this deck does not take advantage of the Commander's abilities by spamming -1/-1 counters.
Problem 2: this deck doesn't really incorporate green's mana ramp or big beasties.
Problem 3: This deck doesn't focus on any of the swampy black mechanics to take control of the game.
I think there is something good here, but it would require swapping out about half the cards. Most of them feel like filler, because that is exactly what they are.
If you want to try playing EDH/Commander, this is how I suggest starting if you already have a collection of cards: throw together a deck and just play, even if it isn't even slightly optimized.
If you don't already collect cardboard crack, the preconstructed decks are already set up with good cards and good synergy. I think you don't really understand a deck unless you build it yourself and refine it over time, but even using a preconstructed deck as a head start with some refinement to suit your playstyle is a good way to go, and less frustrating for new players. Regardless, don't be afraid to just dive in and give it a try!
This is such a cool idea for a deck! I love the snake tokens, and -1/-1 counters have always held a special place in my heart (I'd like to thank Scars Block for that one). As you mentioned, it definitely could use some improvement, so I'd like to add my two cents (from a slightly competitive viewpoint, hope you don't mind). I know you're working off a limited card pool, so I totally understand some of the more unusual card choices.
"Problem 1: this deck does not take advantage of the Commander's abilities by spamming -1/-1 counters."
I agree. I'm seeing maybe two other cards that even make use of -1/-1 counters. The commander's abilities seem...alright, but not really for an EDH format (I don't know what legendaries you had to choose from, but this one seems really difficult to work around.) I'd add more -1/-1 effects into the deck to get those sweet sweet snakes. Also maybe some fear/intimidate effects so you can connect with the commander for more snakes.
"Problem 2: this deck doesn't really incorporate green's mana ramp or big beasties."
It doesn't and it absolutely needs to. EDH is a typically a slower format; you have time to get those fun, higher costed cards out; might as well throw some big spells in and shake up the table. Your mana curves out at like 2-3, you could definitely make room for some higher costing cards if you have them available (and if they're worth it).
"Problem 3: This deck doesn't focus on any of the swampy black mechanics to take control of the game."
Agreed. I noticed a huge lack of the board control, removal, card draw, and card advantage effects that black is known for. These would pair well with your commander needing to connect with your opponent for her to start getting snakey.
EDH is usually a multiplayer format that runs longer. You have time to get some bigger spells out. I'd throw some overcosted but cool effects in there if you have any. I would also replace the soft removal spells like Disfigure with hard removal. (And remove Illness in the Ranks, it kills your snakes.)
When I got into EDH I built my first deck out of my card collection, and the deck ended up being awful. You've clearly done a better job than I did, haha. I can't even imagine trying to make a deck with such a limited pool of cards to choose from. I always encourage people who are interested in EDH to go buy a precon. You're typically getting a well made deck wth good synergy, and getting some real bang for your buck. Then you can build forward from a good base.
Awesome post and deck, and I'm so glad to finally find a MTG community! (I'm game if anybody wants to sling some spells on untap.in or any other method!)
I have already started a much more focused deck. Not optimal by any means, but I got a bunch of wither/infect cards and green ramp from my much larger (if not especially impressive) collection.
I have more effective potential in Golgari, but I wanted to experiment with this mechanic. And not to spoil anything, but the updated deck has an alternative commander I also want to try out... keep an eye on the page on Monday!
Well I'm hyped! I love seeing how people start decks and then change and improve them, especially when you start limited. Infect would be great, along with proliferate (Contagion Clasp anyone?), and big-green sounds like the perfect addition.
I still have a lot of artifacts to go through, so the new deck will certainly continue to evolve.
Oh, I'm glad o have stumbled upon this community because am a MTG fiend.
Gotta have some hobbies so you don't go insane or resort to drink in our crazy world!
Congratulations @jacobtothe! You have completed the following achievement on the Hive blockchain and have been rewarded with new badge(s) :
Your next target is to reach 12000 comments.
You can view your badges on your board and compare yourself to others in the Ranking
If you no longer want to receive notifications, reply to this comment with the word
STOPCheck out the last post from @hivebuzz:
Support the HiveBuzz project. Vote for our proposal!