Making Sense of the Craziness of 2020 Through Love

in #philosophy4 years ago

I don’t think I would have believed you if last year you’d told me 2020 would include governments around the world controlling when you can travel freely, which businesses you can shop at and when, which businesses can remain open or must stay closed, whether or not you can peacefully assemble and in what numbers, forced in-home isolation even with no symptoms, and more while enforcing standards of behavior like mask wearing, distancing, temperature taking, hand washing, hand sanitizing, etc.

How did this happen?

The encouraging thought that hit me this morning was this: this happened because humans are a compassionate, cooperative, loving species.

For liberty minded folks like myself, it’s easy to get discouraged and think it’s just people being “sheeple” and falling unthinkingly in-line with the myth of authority, doing whatever it is they’ve been programmed by their masters to do. On some level, sure this is true, but I believe the deeper reason these policies are still in place and so widely accepted is because they appeal to our compassion. As whole, we don’t want to harm others. As a whole, we are willing to inconvenience ourselves if it protects someone else. As whole, we’re not so selfish to think our preferences give us the right to endanger someone else to weeks or months of suffering and possibly death. That’s the hook behind whether or not all this works.

I know some believe this is all a complete hoax and the tests show too many false positives and the death counts have been misdiagnosed, etc. Even if that’s true, the chance that it’s not true (uncertainty principle applies here) causes people to defer to their love for others. Most people I talk to who proudly wear their masks understand it’s not for them, it’s to protect others in case they are sick but don’t know it yet.

This lockdown is driven, empowered, and effective because of love for each other.

At least, that’s what I choose to believe today. The alternative is to focus on the reproduction of the Milgram experiment in 2015, 50 years after the original, where most people (shockingly 90% of the 80 people involved) where willing to go to the highest level of the experiment, believing they are delivering a harmful shock to an innocent person because an authority told them to do so. We could dwell on this and be discouraged, but again, I choose to find the hook: the milgram experiment is set up as a voluntary agreement. The participants are told they agreed to the arrangement beforehand. Should I judge someone’s BDSM preferences, for example? Would the experiment work the same if those involved were told the other person was their against their will? I think not. The growing attention towards human trafficking demonstrates awareness rising.

No, I choose to believe we care for one another. That’s why we respond so dramatically to news stories of what we consider to be injustice. It’s precisely because we do care so damned much. Our love is a powerful force strong enough to create the 2020 we’re seeing. In a perverse way, even the political drama relates to our need for others around us to be protected and the father figure of President is something many care about because they want everyone to be protected. It’s why many “support the troops” thinking sacrifices are being made on our behalf, which is considered by many as an act of service and an expression of love.

The same physical act can have two completely different meanings based on the intent and circumstance. The proper use of force can be heroic and life saving. It can also be destructive and immature. The key to understanding is knowing what people believe about what they are doing. Only a very small percentage of humanity is actually psychotic (some day around 2%, and even then, at different levels with different coping mechanisms). Most people, even the ones you are absolutely convinced are evil incarnate, justify their actions because of love. It might be love of a movement’s ideals as they understand them. It might be more personal, like the memory of a loved one who wasn’t protected. It could be any number of things with the same driving power behind it all: because we care.

So how do we make sense of 2020?

Find the hook. Isolate and magnify the real, genuine love there. Identify it, honor it, celebrate it, and encourage it. Be open to being wrong about your judgements of it and be courageous enough to talk about that raw vulnerability. When the power of what is thought of as love is misdirected, it can be extremely destructive and dangerous (“love of the motherland”, love of “our dear leader”, love of the “pure race”, etc). That doesn’t mean the need for love or love itself is wrong. It’s a powerful force and like anything powerful, it can build or destroy. What we can do is find real love and direct it towards productive ends for a world we prefer over this present reality.

download.jpeg

“Love is patient, love is kind. It does not envy, it does not boast, it is not proud. It does not dishonor others, it is not self-seeking, it is not easily angered, it keeps no record of wrongs. Love does not delight in evil but rejoices with the truth. It always protects, always trusts, always hopes, always perseveres.”

Search other religious texts and you will see similar descriptions about the unconditional love I’m describing. It’s all around us. It’s powerful. With training, we can find it even among those we might call enemies or humans we believe to be worthy of our hate.

Look for love today. It might help you make sense of what otherwise seems absolutely insane. People in love do crazy things.

Note: I originally published this on Voice, but as you can see here, the formatting got all messed up. More on that here. Until Voice lets you edit posts, I think Hive is still way ahead.

Sort:  

It's been such a strange time. Even if one believes the conspiracies and misunderstandings about the numbers, we still just don't have enough data about the virus to take a risk.

I definitely wear a mask for others. I don't want people to get sick because I was foolish, even if I feel healthy and fine. I'm always disappointed when people to refuse to wear masks, because even if you were 99% sure it was a hoax, wouldn't the 1% uncertainty determine you'd look out for your fellow human beings just in case?

because even if you were 99% sure it was a hoax, wouldn't the 1% uncertainty determine you'd look out for your fellow human beings just in case?

Eh I kinda feel like that might follow the same logic as, "If you have nothing to hide you shouldn't care about privacy."

The political reason to not wear a mask revolves around refusing to consent to an authoritarian state that just decided they can force you to do things if a state-of-emergency is called. Leaders stepped up and decided which businesses to close and which were "essential". What was the criteria? It's a very thin-ice moment that many don't want to see escalate, which is exactly what would happen if everyone accepted these commands blindly and without question.

I'm personally forced to wear a mask every day at work and get my temperature taken by an IR scanner. If not they kick me out of the building. It's not a big deal, until it is. That's how they get ya. The frog boils slowly.

I can definitely see the similarity in logic... but I think it's more nuanced than that. If this was just a couple of countries facing this danger, then sure, but it's every country. Very real people have died and one of my friends and his girlfriend have gotten extremely sick. He basically spends 21 hours a day in bed, a walk up and down his balcony is absolutely exhausting and has said he's had a few close calls with blood clots... he's younger than me and his girlfriend has had quite different symptoms but still quite sick.

He's been told he has covid-19... maybe he doesn't, maybe it is a world-wide conspiracy about control and a transition of wealth from the poor to the rich... but the best information from doctors that he trusts is this is what he has. I don't know what else to do but believe him, and I certainly don't want to either catch it, or inadvertently pass it on.

I totally get what you're saying, and I don't think it's impossible, I just think at this point, with the information I have, that it's more likely that there is a big scary virus going around that we don't have a lot of data on. The alternative requires a level of coordination that I'm just not sure the governments of the world are capable of...

Maybe I'm being totally tricked... but if I am I'm choosing to err on the side of hopefully not causing anyone harm. Once more information comes out, maybe I'll feel silly, but I don't think I'll feel guilty.

I'm not saying there's no virus. I think I had it. super mild case if so. novel viruses are pretty unpredictable.

What I will say is that the six feet rule is super shady, came out of nowhere, and is basically unspoken law... in some cases actual law generating fines.

Go back im time a year ago and ask doctors about this six foot rule. theyd laugh us out the damn room. meanwhile it seems to be okay if 100 people touch the same object as long as theyre 6 feet apart when they do it. like what the actual fuck.

They told us not to wear masks when this started, citing they don't help. Now masks are mandatory and many people have had drama, been fired, or even murdered over the issue. The only constant is that we're being lied to as all the 1984 references become more and more relevant.

Oh yeah! Totally agree on that.

Governments are treating the 6 foot rule like it's a magic thing and as far as I know the science behind the aerosol spread is 6 feet doesn't really matter if the virus is trapped indoors.

I'm not sure if I believe that's governments being evil, or just trying to dumb it down to somehow slow down the spread. 'Don't be inside with feverish fools' is way too hard so the 6 feet thing is something anyone can understand.

Yeah, I think the CDC messed up with the mask thing... other countries were onto masks immediately, and the numbers in South Korea, Japan and China where masks are super common kinda support that.

I truly don't know what works and what doesn't... so I'm basically avoiding all people and being a good mask guy when I can.

I personally have a very unique outlook on all this. The truth doesn't really matter to me. No matter what the truth is, I'm going to perform the same actions. I'm a total hermit so I never go outside anyway. Other people were freaking out going stir-crazy during lockdown and I can still safely say everything that's gone down hasn't really affected my day-to-day like at all. Hopefully it says that way.

Haha, me too!
This time has honestly been great for me. No commute, we're saving a ton of money and I don't have to do awkward small talk. We go out once every 2 weeks for groceries and that's it. I'm more than fine with this lasting another year.

Many government schemes are sold on humanitarian grounds. Welfare, food stamps, UBC, UHC, foreign aid, police state actions, military intervention, whatever, the sales pitch usually includes an assertion that submission means caring about the poor, the sick, and the oppressed. That appeal to compassion is what lets them get away with awful power grabs.

This perverse manipulation of our better traits disgusts me, but you're right, it's also a glimmer of hope that people can learn to look beyond that sales pitch. It also disproves the claim that people are inherently monsters without governmental guidance.

https://www.cdc.gov/nchs/nvss/vsrr/covid_weekly/index.htm

I hear that the CDC recently and quietly reduced the number of COVID deaths by a factor of twenty. What a surprise.

I hope some of your idealism pushes its way into the future.
Good people need good leaders to follow.

The encouraging thought that hit me this morning was this: this happened because humans are a compassionate, cooperative, loving species.

This lockdown is driven, empowered, and effective because of love for each other.

At least, that’s what I choose to believe today.

> Revelation 13: 16-17
Also it causes all, both small and great, both rich and poor, both free and slave, to be marked on the right hand or the forehead, so that no one can buy or sell unless he has the mark, that is, the name of the beast or the number of its name.

Well, I'm not a religious person @lukestokes. But as the incurable "defensive pessimist" that I am, I would suggest that you now read the post and the comments, of which from one of those comments, was where I took the religious quote above with which I start my own comment here.

And once you have done it, then come back here, reread your own post again and evaluate if your altruistic optimism still remains the same and if you wouldn't feel with some desire of editing your post in the least.

Excuse me if this comment can be perceived as aggressive or something. It's not. I have nothing against you or your post either. It's just that I thought that it would be worth adding some more "Food for Thought" on the subject of your article. :)

Cheers!!

I have great respect for the Cobert Report while I also think we create the reality we allow. What can become a totalitarian hell hole can also become a utopian paradise. These are all just tools we're talking about and how we use them matters. Those who want to control others will continue to use the tools available to do so. Not creating tools anymore is a luddite approach which doesn't make sense to me. I think physical cash is quite silly. I also think privacy is important. I think things like Monero can help (and yes, I did hear the recent news claiming they can figure out stuff, but I'm not convinced it's anything more than a scare tactic).

I appreciate your perspective. Thank you for sharing.

I also think we create the reality we allow.

Yes, pretty much yeah!

These are all just tools we're talking about and how we use them matters. Those who want to control others will continue to use the tools available to do so.

I'm not really sure if I've stumbled across too much data and information from the other side of the fence or something lately. And for the same reason I am now a bit doubting whether to share or not with you another link with massive reports that deep down I suspect you would like to explore too.

But anyhow, I bet you can endure anyway. So, here we go!!

What can become a totalitarian hell hole can also become a utopian paradise.

That's right my dear friend. But I think that for us, the curious ones with good hearts, it never hurts to stay as well informed as possible so that the 'remote and the unexpected' do not take us by surprise. };)