You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Defending “Moo! Wrapper” & “Distributed.net”

in #gridcoin6 years ago
  1. The question as presented is not fair and is leading the voter.

This is a very good point regarding voting process.

Good thing about Moo!-gate is that it clearly shows we lack several policies and criteria for decision making. Apart of technical criteria you have covered in your whitelist-greylist proposal, non technical once are also needed.
If the project complies with technical requirements:

  • should any project run on BOINC platform be eligible to be whitelisted? (It's just a software solution, thousands of projects could be created)
  • is scientific purpose a requirement?
  • is usefulness required? (How can we be sure about our judgement on usefulness?)
  • if other methods allow to find solution quickly or solution is known, should the project using non-effective methods be incorporated into Gridcoin Network?
  • .........
Sort:  

If you want to make sure your say is recorded, I would appreciate if you post it here:

https://github.com/gridcoin-community/Gridcoin-Tasks/issues/201

I split the de-listing out of the current proposal as it obviously needed more work with the current controversy.