You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: What Do You think of Scott Ritter's comments on the Ukraine?

in Deep Dives11 months ago

I've seen discussions of Poland becoming the leader of a central and eastern Europe bloc of nations, incorporating Belarus and W. Ukraine, while W. Europe degenerates into penury. Ritter isn't alone in understanding the Ukraine is no longer potential to be a country. The people of the Donbas aren't just 'ethnic Russians'. They are family members of people living in Russia. The Donbas was cut out of the Ukraine by Right Sector and Azov when they were pushed by the CIA into waging genocidal war against it.

The rest of the Ukraine has variously been Lithuanian, Polish, and Russian for centuries. The Ukraine means 'the hinterlands', and it has always been the route to Europe for steppe barbarians invading, or into Russia for conquistadors. It's geographically a corridor for war, not a viable nation. This isn't just relevant in historic times, but clear back to Neolithic times, and probably farther than we have the archaeological acumen to ascertain.

UkraineRomanDmowski1930.png

Dmowski was right then, and he's right today. Adventurers and ready men have always been the Ukraines primary resource. As long as it's not divvied up into it's neighbors, like Kurdistan, so it will remain.

Thanks!

Sort:  

It seems dividing it might be the only peaceful negotiation left on the table, I have heard about the Donbas heritage there being deeply Russian as well, all the way to Odessa appearantly is Russia. The W. Ukraine would probably loose access to the port, and it wouldn't surprise me if Russia pushed for that in diplomatic negotiation.

During my travel in Ukraine, besides amazing hospitable people, I experienced 3 facts:

  • west of the Dniepr it is 90% Russian
  • Ukrainian was only spoken in a small area in the west
  • many people liked me being an Austrian because we produced such a great leader in the 30s....

mostly west of dniepr, maybe west of kiev.
In the south (odesa, krim) not at all.

Can you indicate a link to where I can view those pics? I can't see them here.