Red Flags: How to Avoid Choosing the Wrong PhD Supervisor

To those of you who are looking for a PhD supervisor, please remember that finding the right PhD supervisor is a critical aspect of a successful and fulfilling doctoral journey.

Sometimes, knowing what to avoid is just as important as knowing what to look for in a potential supervisor. Here are what came to mind.

• Lack of expertise in your research area
  Avoid supervisors who lack recent publications or have limited expertise in your research area, as they may not provide the necessary guidance and support. Make sure to thoroughly research their publication records and projects before deciding. You are going to learn to do your research well, so make sure he/she knows way more than you!

• Inadequate student selection process
  Steer clear of supervisors who accept numerous students without a thorough selection process. These supervisors may be more focused on their own success than their students' needs. They may think that each student is an asset that can help them with their research, so they tend to accept many students. Don't be one of them!

• Poor interpersonal skills
  Be wary of supervisors who appear dismissive, arrogant, or unapproachable, as these traits may hinder effective communication and collaboration. Observe their interactions with colleagues and students to assess their interpersonal skills. If you can't talk to your supervisor or find it hard to bring up your ideas, he/she is not the right supervisor.

• Vague expectations
  Avoid supervisors who do not clearly communicate their expectations or provide vague guidelines. This lack of transparency may lead to misunderstandings and conflict during your PhD journey. If you can't avoid it, to deal with this, you may have to take notes and show him/her the notes after every meeting!

• Uninspiring and unmotivated
  Be cautious of supervisors who display a lack of enthusiasm or passion for their field. These supervisors may struggle to inspire and motivate you throughout your PhD journey. Those nearing retirements tend to be less motivated... just saying.

• Unwillingness to provide guidance and support
  Avoid supervisors who appear disinterested in your research ideas or unwilling to provide guidance. This may hinder your project's development and leave you feeling unsupported. Some academic staff are very capable, but they may not want to share their knowledge. Avoid them!

• Low student completion rates
  Be cautious of supervisors with low completion rates or a history of students taking significantly longer to finish their PhD. This may indicate inadequate supervision and support. This is the best tell tale sign!

• Inadequate or overly critical feedback
  Avoid supervisors who rarely provide feedback or are overly critical without offering constructive suggestions. This may hinder your progress and damage your confidence. Eventually, your motivation may wane.

• Poor conflict management skills
  Be wary of supervisors who avoid addressing conflicts or leave their resolution entirely to the students. This may create an unhealthy working environment and impede your progress. This is poor leadership!

• Lack of commitment to research quality
  Be cautious of supervisors with limited publication records or whose students consistently publish in low-impact journals. This may indicate a lack of commitment to research quality and impact your future academic career. Again, you want to learn from the best, so publication record is a good indicator.

• Unwillingness to address challenges
  Avoid supervisors who appear unwilling to address potential challenges or do not offer practical solutions. This may hinder your ability to adapt and progress during your research. You want someone tenacious to emulate!

• Neglect of research standards
  Be cautious of supervisors who do not emphasize research integrity or have a history of ethical breaches. This may negatively impact your research and reputation. Something no one should compromise!

• Lack of support for professional development
  Avoid supervisors who do not prioritize their students' professional development or neglect to support them in attending conferences, workshops, and networking events. Good supervisors always watch your back!

Conclusion

By being aware of these red flags, you can avoid choosing the wrong PhD supervisor and instead find a supervisor who will support, guide, and inspire you throughout your PhD journey. Remember that finding the right supervisor is a critical aspect of your success, so take your time, do your research, and trust your instincts when making this important decision.

Picture Source