You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: The Macro Moment: Why Economists Should Be Ignored

in Threespeak2 months ago

Summary:
In this video, the speaker passionately discusses his belief that economists are usually wrong and that much of what they discuss is nonsense. He asserts that economics is not a real science like physics or chemistry, noting that economists simply observe and create models without directly contributing to the economy. The speaker argues against the commonly held economic theory that deflation discourages purchasing by providing real-world examples such as the semiconductor industry and the increasing adoption of deflationary products like smartphones and solar panels.

Detailed Article:
The speaker vehemently expresses his skepticism towards economists and their theories, labeling much of their discourse as nonsensical. He begins by recounting his own experience studying economics, where he eventually realized that the professors, despite their expertise, actually lacked practical knowledge and were merely theorizing about past events without adding tangible value to the economy. The speaker challenges the credibility of economics as a field, particularly in contrast to traditional sciences like physics or chemistry.

He argues that economists mainly focus on observation and creating models rather than actively contributing to economic growth or business development. The speaker criticizes the entire field of economics, stating that it serves no purpose and does not assist in enhancing productivity or generating economic output. He emphasizes that economists are merely theoretical and do not engage in the practical aspects of running a business, such as meeting payrolls, employing people, or generating revenues.

A significant portion of the video is dedicated to debunking the economic theory of deflation, which suggests that lower prices in the future discourage immediate purchases. The speaker counters this theory by illustrating examples from various industries, including semiconductors, smartphones, batteries, and solar panels, where despite the deflationary trends, sales continue to rise year over year. He emphasizes how consumers are aware of future price reductions but still make purchases, challenging the economists' narrative on deflation's impact on consumer behavior.

Moreover, the speaker highlights the role of Wall Street traders and professionals in understanding the flow of capital and real-world economic dynamics. He suggests that individuals with trading experience have a better understanding of economic principles because they have practical exposure to market fluctuations and the consequences of theoretical inaccuracies.

In conclusion, the speaker encourages the audience to be critical of economic theories and to seek out practitioners with practical experience in the financial markets. He underscores the disconnect between economic theory and real-world economic activities, using examples like the semiconductor industry's growth to support his argument. The video serves as a thought-provoking critique of traditional economic thinking and highlights the speaker's skepticism towards conventional economic wisdom.