"Something a Libertarian should never be for."
I understand your point. Seems valid. But I think that such libertarian stance clashes with pragmatism on political level where "decision makers" have to choose among not ideal solutions. I don't consider idea of society where everyone is libertarian as possible to obtain.
That's fair and I can see why. A lot of people see a true libertarian based society as not practical. I don't personally agree. I think there is a way to apply such principals in a practical and real way. But I respect your opinion.
It's true life isn't always black and white. There is often a not perfect solution. Yet I think in almost all situation which remains more true to the Libertarian belief.