Actually, I was not a fan of a way that Collection Power is calculated! I even made a post about it and this was Yaba response: https://peakd.com/hive-13323/@yabapmatt/re-jacekw-qell5k
You both have some good reasons for your positions.
You suggested similar things like I did in my comment above (not to differentiate between gold and non-gold etc.).
However, I (as an example) don't care so much if I am on top in Diamond League or 'anywhere' in Champions League (if players with some skills and a good deck invest enough time they can get their piece of the cake anyhow and anyway). If you reach a certain level you can have at least some fun or try to reach even more.
What really worries me is the playing experience of players with more or less mediocre decks and non-expert skills. I understand that not everybody can (and should) earn a lot, but I think at least they should have some fun (I think that if the player base of Splinterlands should grow that will only happen with the big majority of these players who aren't fighting for top Champions League spots)!
When as a test I used the deck of a friend to see how it feels to make a simple quest for him, I have to admit it was really frustrating: very strong opponents (in comparison with his deck), "grinding an hour or more" (as @cmplxty wrote) and then winning a few potions ...
Maybe in lower leagues one could reduce at least the necessary number of games to fulfill a quest (as compensation for the low rewards)?
But that's just one idea, and we need to do more to increase playing experience of non-professional players.
Yeah the experience of the folks in the lower leagues shouldn’t necessarily match those in the leagues of diamond and champion. We want it to definitely be fun to play and they should enjoy the game instead of loathe the lame reward they will receive.
I see both worlds with my accounts. My main account oh this username has decent collection power to hold my own in gold and diamond leagues. My alt account, the gold foil account, it’s not as strong but it’s often very challenging to do a daily quest if it’s not a dragon or a life quest. Sometimes I just skip it entirely and gain a little DEC to compensate for the loss of chests and wait for the following day to try.
I just hope that the Splinterlands team will take all of our thoughts here into consideration. There’s a heck of a lot of great merit to go around and definitely some things to chew on for adjustments.
I appreciate everyone’s dialogue here, I don’t feel as frustrated now that folks are agreeing and modifying my proposals and highlighting others they came up with. All around great stuff!