You are viewing a single comment's thread from:

RE: Initial Coin Offerings with SMTs

in #smt5 years ago

There are a few mitigations in place already.

We are repurposing existing code as much as possible. We are taking functions that were created to work only with STEEM and making them generic to work with SMTs without changing the functionality. This gives us a greater confidence in a large percentage of the behavior of SMTs as these functions have been battle tested over the last three and a half years. It is not a guarantee, but a high degree of confidence.

We are reserving more of our time for testing SMTs than we have with previous releases.

If there is a bug in SMTs, it will cause a chain halt for everyone. This will allow us to not only fix to first buggy token, but also fix every other SMT at the same time. It will also avoid situations like Ethereum Classic. Because the entire chain will halt, a bug with one token won't require rolling back the entire network and will keep everyone's coins safe.

Sort:  

The whole Steem chain will halt? Oof, we've had a lot of that. Please test in larger environments than before.

Posted using Partiko Android

While blockchain halts suck, the other options are much worse. I will take a temporary halt any day of the week if they don’t happen often. Plus, state files will be a big improvement for getting the chain up and running again if I understand them correctly.

If there is a bug in SMTs, it will cause a chain halt for everyone.

This is what I would call "outsourcing of testing and debug onto a public chain".
Not to think of any other reasons one could use this against Stem itself..

Well, were there any bugs in the testnet?
Has the testnet even been tested?

That's a creative solution for handling bugs that could create a situation where the chain would otherwise have to be rolled back. Definitely the lesser of two evils.

Is there a quick way to mitigate such an occurrence while the problem with the code is diagnosed and corrected?